Naruto is a Japanese animation television series which came out in 1999 in
The clip of Naruto which I chose to analyze is one where the titular character of Naruto and his team of ninjas, led by his sensei Kakashi, go on their first real mission to protect a bridge builder and protect him until he is done building his bridge. They end up fighting a dangerous criminal named Zabuza, who has a little protégé name Haku. Both are high level criminals who the team eventually ends up getting the upper hand on and, for the most part, beat them. Haku dies protecting Zabuza just a little bit before the clip starts. After that, the rich businessman, who was paying Zabuza to keep the bridge from being built in order to prevent free trade, shows up with an army of thugs to take care of Zabuza and Naruto’s team. Zabuza had just lost use of his arms from the fight, and so he asks Naruto for a Kunai, which he uses with his mouth. Zabuza ends up killing off the sleazy businessman and dying himself from being stabbed by the thugs. Zabuza then ends up dying, hallucinating up an image of Haku in his last few seconds.
I am going to look at this clip from two different perspectives. The first one is looking at it in terms of the cliché good and evil with an added heaven and hell aspect to it. Zabuza is, right before the clip, an evil sort of person, defending his evil boss, the rich businessman. Then he changes his to a good person when he realizes the error of his ways through the death of Haku. He stands with the good people, and rips off his bandages, which hid his true good character underneath. He uses the weapon of the good guys, the kunai and tears through a crowd of evil thugs to reach the most evil person, the rich businessman. Zabuza, bearing his evil nature, kills the businessman and thereafter, his repented soul is carried into death, the memory of Haku bringing him to repentance.
Another way of looking at this clip is as a battle between the classes. Zabuza, being a criminal with an unclean appearance and slang ridden speech, is a great example of someone who is lower class. The rich businessman is an example of someone of the higher class, who attempts to manipulate those lower than him. They are not quite at the lower class level in terms of how they live, but they are not of high class living. However, when Zabuza goes after the rich businessman and successfully kills him with relative ease, it perpetuates the stereotype that low class people are strong and dangerous, very capable and very willing to kill, while high class people tend to have little ability to fight and therefore hire other people to do their dirty work for them, hence the thugs. In relation to what Gramsci writes, according to the hegemony theory paper, the lower class in this clip is struggling against the upper class for his own reality. In this regard, the upper class person is depicted as a bad person trying to control and set limits in the lower person, with the lower class person being more of a hero type character, trying to fight for freedom.
Also present in this clip is the portrayal of power. It is almost clearly in the hands of Zabuza, despite his lower class. It is when he dies at the end that he relinquishes his power (because he dies). The rich businessman, who is supposed to have power through his riches, has some power through the thugs whom he controls, but it pales in comparison to someone who earned his power through hard work, a Japanese ideal. It is through this power in his hands that the Japanese ideal overpowers the power of upper class and is shown to be more important.
4 comments:
First let me say out that this has to be by far my favorite blog entry because this is one of my favorite moment in Naruto and I wont lie and say that I did cry over the death of Haku but only in an emotional state of weakness I tell you. lol.
Second, I think that it is important that you looked at this clip from a number of points and not just the standard way to look at it with it being a fight between good and evil.
I think the way you looked at the clip was really good because those are key points in the build up of Zabuza breaking down and finally becoming human with his feelings towards Haku and how he treated him in general. Since one of the main points is that Zabuza breaks his class structure and destroys those he was working for which helps him save himself before death.
I like the way you looked at this very much and think you clearly got what was trying to be presented in the fight between the two. Also I like the last idea you presented with the Japanese ideal, where while a group is important the act of being able to over come and through hard work you can become something more.
Great job!
I can see how Naruto is a favorite for adults. I had a mis-conception on what it was all about. The graphics are not what I thought, I thought the show would be more for younger viewers. However, I can see teens and up in age starting to watch this.
Your two view about good and bad and then different classes are definitely seen in the clip you have. I will honestly say that I am not a huge Naruto fan, but I thought of the movie "West Side Story". It's probably because of the different groups and the death of one of the gang member in the movie.
This anime is for the adults with all the adult sub-text. I don't see kids or parents letting them watch it due to all the violence. Enjoyed learning about Naruto and will watch if I come across it when changing the channels.
I agree with the others that you did a really good job. I haven't really watched this show and don't know much about it. You mentioned that the criminals who are in the lower class use a lot more slang. This seems to be a prevailing theme in American entertainment so it makes me wonder if that is what the creators intended or if it just something that got added in translation.
You did a good job of analyzing the clip, especially considering the fact that I think it was a little harder to do for those of us who picked a topic that is animated or revolved around characters who are not human. I think because I am not too familiar with anime there's certain aspects of the show that I would not have picked up on, like what you mentioned at the end about the Japanese ideal regarding power.
Post a Comment